Quebec’s Ombudsman and children’s rights advocates argue these extreme measures cross ethical lines to vulnerable young people. Such intense searches serve little purpose when alternatives exist. Children’s rights advocates warn of long-term mental health scars tied to these humiliating procedures.

The Director of Youth Protection (DPJ) now plans to allow such intrusive measures only in emergencies, marking a clear change. This restricted access aims to balance safety with care for young people’s mental health. Courts and oversight bodies are urged to prevent overreach in these cases.

The Association des centres jeunesse du Québec supports this shift fully. They say cautious reforms protect minors better while keeping centres secure. Youth centres in regions like the Mauricie-Centre-du-Québec have already seen fewer complaints by cutting back on these searches. Redirecting focus from harsh measures to prevention training is proving more effective. Growth comes before control in these settings.

Critics insist the old ways won’t work . They argue excessive controls miss the point . Adequate training and alternative safety measures must replace outdated tactics. No child should face such trauma .